On August 24, 2025 1:06:07 PM GMT+02:00, Pascal Stumpf <pascal@stumpf.co> wrote:
>On Sun, 24 Aug 2025 12:33:10 +0200, Antoine Jacoutot wrote:
>> On Sat, Aug 23, 2025 at 03:50:21PM +0200, Theo Buehler wrote:
>> > > The KSH found at configure time is propagated to most scripts that are
>> > > installed.  It's quite possible that all of these work as intended with
>> > > /bin/ksh, but maybe it's best to not take any chances.
>> > 
>> > Depending on shells/ksh93 is problematic due to the conflict with
>> > devel/libast. Now both have consumers, so the conflict bit me in my
>> > last bulk:
>> 
>> Thanks for the head up.
>> What about statically compiling ksh?
>
>I'd rather keep libshell, how about a subpackage?
>
>
>Index: Makefile
>===================================================================
>RCS file: /home/cvs/ports/shells/ksh93/Makefile,v
>diff -u -p -r1.25 Makefile
>--- Makefile	1 Sep 2024 09:54:01 -0000	1.25
>+++ Makefile	24 Aug 2025 11:01:14 -0000
>@@ -1,11 +1,14 @@
>-COMMENT =		AT&T Korn Shell
>+COMMENT-main =		AT&T Korn Shell
>+COMMENT-libshell =	AT&T Korn Shell, dynamic libraries
> 
> V =			1.0.10
> GH_ACCOUNT =		ksh93
> GH_PROJECT =		ksh
> GH_TAGNAME =		v${V}
>-PKGNAME =		ksh93-$V
>-EPOCH =			0
>+PKGNAME-main =		ksh93-$V
>+PKGNAME-libshell =	libshell-$V
>+EPOCH-main =		0
>+REVISION-main =		0
> 
> SO_VERSION =		0.0
> 
>@@ -16,6 +19,8 @@ SHARED_LIBS +=  shell                   
> 
> CATEGORIES =		shells
> 
>+MULTI_PACKAGES =	-main -libshell
>+
> HOMEPAGE =		https://github.com/ksh93/ksh
> 
> MAINTAINER =		Pascal Stumpf <pascal@stumpf.co>
>@@ -40,7 +45,7 @@ do-build:
> 		HOSTTYPE="${HOSTTYPE}"
> 
> do-install:
>-	${INSTALL_PROGRAM} ${AST_ARCH}/dyn/bin/ksh ${PREFIX}/bin/ksh93
>+	${INSTALL_PROGRAM} ${AST_ARCH}/bin/ksh ${PREFIX}/bin/ksh93
> 	cd ${PREFIX}/bin && ln ksh93 rksh93
> 	${INSTALL_DATA} ${AST_ARCH}/lib/lib{ast,cmd,dll,shell}.a \
> 		${PREFIX}/lib
>Index: pkg/DESCR
>===================================================================
>RCS file: pkg/DESCR
>diff -N pkg/DESCR
>--- pkg/DESCR	13 Oct 2012 15:11:51 -0000	1.1.1.1
>+++ /dev/null	1 Jan 1970 00:00:00 -0000
>@@ -1,11 +0,0 @@
>-KSH-93 is the most recent version of the KornShell Language described
>-in "The KornShell Command and Programming Language," by Morris
>-Bolsky and David Korn of AT&T Bell Laboratories.  The KornShell is
>-a shell programming language, which is upward compatible with "sh"
>-(the Bourne Shell), and is intended to conform to the IEEE P1003.2/ISO
>-9945.2 Shell and Utilities standard.  KSH-93 provides an enhanced
>-programming environment in addition to the major command-entry
>-features of the BSD shell "csh".  With KSH-93, medium-sized programming
>-tasks can be performed at shell-level without a significant loss
>-in performance.  In addition, "sh" scripts can be run on KSH-93
>-without modification.
>Index: pkg/DESCR-libshell
>===================================================================
>RCS file: pkg/DESCR-libshell
>diff -N pkg/DESCR-libshell
>--- /dev/null	1 Jan 1970 00:00:00 -0000
>+++ pkg/DESCR-libshell	24 Aug 2025 11:02:21 -0000
>@@ -0,0 +1,13 @@
>+KSH-93 is the most recent version of the KornShell Language described
>+in "The KornShell Command and Programming Language," by Morris
>+Bolsky and David Korn of AT&T Bell Laboratories.  The KornShell is
>+a shell programming language, which is upward compatible with "sh"
>+(the Bourne Shell), and is intended to conform to the IEEE P1003.2/ISO
>+9945.2 Shell and Utilities standard.  KSH-93 provides an enhanced
>+programming environment in addition to the major command-entry
>+features of the BSD shell "csh".  With KSH-93, medium-sized programming
>+tasks can be performed at shell-level without a significant loss
>+in performance.  In addition, "sh" scripts can be run on KSH-93
>+without modification.
>+
>+This package contains the dynamic libraries and headers.
>Index: pkg/DESCR-main
>===================================================================
>RCS file: pkg/DESCR-main
>diff -N pkg/DESCR-main
>--- /dev/null	1 Jan 1970 00:00:00 -0000
>+++ pkg/DESCR-main	13 Oct 2012 15:11:51 -0000
>@@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
>+KSH-93 is the most recent version of the KornShell Language described
>+in "The KornShell Command and Programming Language," by Morris
>+Bolsky and David Korn of AT&T Bell Laboratories.  The KornShell is
>+a shell programming language, which is upward compatible with "sh"
>+(the Bourne Shell), and is intended to conform to the IEEE P1003.2/ISO
>+9945.2 Shell and Utilities standard.  KSH-93 provides an enhanced
>+programming environment in addition to the major command-entry
>+features of the BSD shell "csh".  With KSH-93, medium-sized programming
>+tasks can be performed at shell-level without a significant loss
>+in performance.  In addition, "sh" scripts can be run on KSH-93
>+without modification.
>Index: pkg/PLIST
>===================================================================
>RCS file: pkg/PLIST
>diff -N pkg/PLIST
>--- pkg/PLIST	1 Sep 2024 09:54:01 -0000	1.6
>+++ /dev/null	1 Jan 1970 00:00:00 -0000
>@@ -1,122 +0,0 @@
>-@conflict libast-*
>-@shell bin/ksh93
>-@shell bin/rksh93
>-include/ast/
>-include/ast/align.h
>-include/ast/aso.h
>-include/ast/ast.h
>-include/ast/ast_api.h
>-include/ast/ast_ccode.h
>-include/ast/ast_common.h
>-include/ast/ast_dir.h
>-include/ast/ast_dirent.h
>-include/ast/ast_fcntl.h
>-include/ast/ast_float.h
>-include/ast/ast_fs.h
>-include/ast/ast_iconv.h
>-include/ast/ast_lib.h
>-include/ast/ast_limits.h
>-include/ast/ast_map.h
>-include/ast/ast_mmap.h
>-include/ast/ast_mode.h
>-include/ast/ast_ndbm.h
>-include/ast/ast_nl_types.h
>-include/ast/ast_param.h
>-include/ast/ast_sizeof.h
>-include/ast/ast_standards.h
>-include/ast/ast_std.h
>-include/ast/ast_stdio.h
>-include/ast/ast_sys.h
>-include/ast/ast_time.h
>-include/ast/ast_tty.h
>-include/ast/ast_wait.h
>-include/ast/ast_wchar.h
>-include/ast/ast_wctype.h
>-include/ast/ast_windows.h
>-include/ast/bytesex.h
>-include/ast/ccode.h
>-include/ast/cdt.h
>-include/ast/cmd.h
>-include/ast/cmdarg.h
>-include/ast/cmdext.h
>-include/ast/cmdlist.h
>-include/ast/debug.h
>-include/ast/dirent.h
>-include/ast/dlldefs.h
>-include/ast/endian.h
>-include/ast/error.h
>-include/ast/find.h
>-include/ast/fmtmsg.h
>-include/ast/fnmatch.h
>-include/ast/fnv.h
>-include/ast/fts.h
>-include/ast/ftw.h
>-include/ast/ftwalk.h
>-include/ast/glob.h
>-include/ast/hash.h
>-include/ast/hashkey.h
>-include/ast/hashpart.h
>-include/ast/history.h
>-include/ast/iconv.h
>-include/ast/ip6.h
>-include/ast/lc.h
>-include/ast/ls.h
>-include/ast/magic.h
>-include/ast/magicid.h
>-include/ast/mc.h
>-include/ast/mime.h
>-include/ast/mnt.h
>-include/ast/modecanon.h
>-include/ast/modex.h
>-include/ast/namval.h
>-include/ast/nl_types.h
>-include/ast/nval.h
>-include/ast/option.h
>-include/ast/proc.h
>-include/ast/re_comp.h
>-include/ast/recfmt.h
>-include/ast/regex.h
>-include/ast/regexp.h
>-include/ast/releaseflags.h
>-include/ast/sfdisc.h
>-include/ast/sfio.h
>-include/ast/sfio_s.h
>-include/ast/sfio_t.h
>-include/ast/shcmd.h
>-include/ast/shell.h
>-include/ast/sig.h
>-include/ast/stak.h
>-include/ast/stdio.h
>-include/ast/stk.h
>-include/ast/sum.h
>-include/ast/swap.h
>-include/ast/tar.h
>-include/ast/times.h
>-include/ast/tm.h
>-include/ast/tmx.h
>-include/ast/tok.h
>-include/ast/tv.h
>-include/ast/vdb.h
>-include/ast/wait.h
>-include/ast/wchar.h
>-include/ast/wctype.h
>-include/ast/wordexp.h
>-@static-lib lib/libast.a
>-@lib lib/libast.so.${LIBast_VERSION}
>-@static-lib lib/libcmd.a
>-@lib lib/libcmd.so.${LIBcmd_VERSION}
>-@static-lib lib/libdll.a
>-@lib lib/libdll.so.${LIBdll_VERSION}
>-@static-lib lib/libshell.a
>-@lib lib/libshell.so.${LIBshell_VERSION}
>-@man man/man1/ksh93.1
>-@man man/man1/rksh93.1
>-@man man/man3/shell.3
>-share/examples/ksh93/
>-share/examples/ksh93/autocd
>-share/examples/ksh93/cd
>-share/examples/ksh93/dirs
>-share/examples/ksh93/man
>-share/examples/ksh93/mcd
>-share/examples/ksh93/popd
>-share/examples/ksh93/pushd
>Index: pkg/PLIST-libshell
>===================================================================
>RCS file: pkg/PLIST-libshell
>diff -N pkg/PLIST-libshell
>--- /dev/null	1 Jan 1970 00:00:00 -0000
>+++ pkg/PLIST-libshell	24 Aug 2025 11:00:22 -0000
>@@ -0,0 +1,110 @@
>+@conflict libast-*
>+include/ast/
>+include/ast/align.h
>+include/ast/aso.h
>+include/ast/ast.h
>+include/ast/ast_api.h
>+include/ast/ast_ccode.h
>+include/ast/ast_common.h
>+include/ast/ast_dir.h
>+include/ast/ast_dirent.h
>+include/ast/ast_fcntl.h
>+include/ast/ast_float.h
>+include/ast/ast_fs.h
>+include/ast/ast_iconv.h
>+include/ast/ast_lib.h
>+include/ast/ast_limits.h
>+include/ast/ast_map.h
>+include/ast/ast_mmap.h
>+include/ast/ast_mode.h
>+include/ast/ast_ndbm.h
>+include/ast/ast_nl_types.h
>+include/ast/ast_param.h
>+include/ast/ast_sizeof.h
>+include/ast/ast_standards.h
>+include/ast/ast_std.h
>+include/ast/ast_stdio.h
>+include/ast/ast_sys.h
>+include/ast/ast_time.h
>+include/ast/ast_tty.h
>+include/ast/ast_wait.h
>+include/ast/ast_wchar.h
>+include/ast/ast_wctype.h
>+include/ast/ast_windows.h
>+include/ast/bytesex.h
>+include/ast/ccode.h
>+include/ast/cdt.h
>+include/ast/cmd.h
>+include/ast/cmdarg.h
>+include/ast/cmdext.h
>+include/ast/cmdlist.h
>+include/ast/debug.h
>+include/ast/dirent.h
>+include/ast/dlldefs.h
>+include/ast/endian.h
>+include/ast/error.h
>+include/ast/find.h
>+include/ast/fmtmsg.h
>+include/ast/fnmatch.h
>+include/ast/fnv.h
>+include/ast/fts.h
>+include/ast/ftw.h
>+include/ast/ftwalk.h
>+include/ast/glob.h
>+include/ast/hash.h
>+include/ast/hashkey.h
>+include/ast/hashpart.h
>+include/ast/history.h
>+include/ast/iconv.h
>+include/ast/ip6.h
>+include/ast/lc.h
>+include/ast/ls.h
>+include/ast/magic.h
>+include/ast/magicid.h
>+include/ast/mc.h
>+include/ast/mime.h
>+include/ast/mnt.h
>+include/ast/modecanon.h
>+include/ast/modex.h
>+include/ast/namval.h
>+include/ast/nl_types.h
>+include/ast/nval.h
>+include/ast/option.h
>+include/ast/proc.h
>+include/ast/re_comp.h
>+include/ast/recfmt.h
>+include/ast/regex.h
>+include/ast/regexp.h
>+include/ast/releaseflags.h
>+include/ast/sfdisc.h
>+include/ast/sfio.h
>+include/ast/sfio_s.h
>+include/ast/sfio_t.h
>+include/ast/shcmd.h
>+include/ast/shell.h
>+include/ast/sig.h
>+include/ast/stak.h
>+include/ast/stdio.h
>+include/ast/stk.h
>+include/ast/sum.h
>+include/ast/swap.h
>+include/ast/tar.h
>+include/ast/times.h
>+include/ast/tm.h
>+include/ast/tmx.h
>+include/ast/tok.h
>+include/ast/tv.h
>+include/ast/vdb.h
>+include/ast/wait.h
>+include/ast/wchar.h
>+include/ast/wctype.h
>+include/ast/wordexp.h
>+@static-lib lib/libast.a
>+@lib lib/libast.so.${LIBast_VERSION}
>+@static-lib lib/libcmd.a
>+@lib lib/libcmd.so.${LIBcmd_VERSION}
>+@static-lib lib/libdll.a
>+@lib lib/libdll.so.${LIBdll_VERSION}
>+@static-lib lib/libshell.a
>+@lib lib/libshell.so.${LIBshell_VERSION}
>+@man man/man3/shell.3
>Index: pkg/PLIST-main
>===================================================================
>RCS file: pkg/PLIST-main
>diff -N pkg/PLIST-main
>--- /dev/null	1 Jan 1970 00:00:00 -0000
>+++ pkg/PLIST-main	24 Aug 2025 11:03:55 -0000
>@@ -0,0 +1,13 @@
>+@pkgpath shells/ksh93
>+@shell bin/ksh93
>+@shell bin/rksh93
>+@man man/man1/ksh93.1
>+@man man/man1/rksh93.1
>+share/examples/ksh93/
>+share/examples/ksh93/autocd
>+share/examples/ksh93/cd
>+share/examples/ksh93/dirs
>+share/examples/ksh93/man
>+share/examples/ksh93/mcd
>+share/examples/ksh93/popd
>+share/examples/ksh93/pushd

No strong opinion ony side but would ksh93 work without also installing the libshell sub package?


--
Antoine